Rainbow over the minicipality

Rainbow over the minicipality

Saturday, 12 September 2015

It is presumptuous of me



It is presumptuous of me to attribute my ideas to the mind of God, but I am that arrogant, deep within myself, far from the surface of self that fractally separate’s from “out there”, so I do.
After Jews wrote down the six booms of the Mishna that they had kept as oral literature for centuries, necessitated by the destruction of the Temple by Rome, and had collected all the traditional sayings of the Rabbis and written down the two Gmearras, creating the Babylonian and Jerusalem Talmuds, then I imagine the Universal Mind observing that Jews still did not understand the purpose of it all.
Certainly some Jews found the true meaning within the performance of all the rituals and within the multiple repetitions of word-embodied ideas.  However most people learnt to perform all these rituals and repeat the formulae of words without losing their inner sense of self.  The “I” that thinks and therefore knows it exists is an illusion.  Hindu and Budhist teaching is that the “ego” is false.  Those who succeed find true bliss, others, like me just wonder at it and wander up dusty lanes.
What was needed was another Prophet who can explain to people that the intent of the complex practices is not the practices themselves, but the act of submission to a higher consciousness and the abandonment of the false sense of “self” that everyone is born with.  “Islam” is “submission”.  It has the practices and the recitations, but the intent is exactly the same for Orthodox Jews.
Twice in the last two decades I have started to become religious.  It came very naturally to me when I was struck with grief at the sudden death of my dearly beloved Father.  I made it through the mandatory year and about another month, before the “all or nothing” requirement got to me.  My sense of me, my ego was too strong.  Perhaps it was because I have always been an extreme introvert, and my “self” is buried deep within me, far from the real world.  No one has ever succeeded in penetrating into my psyche or sense of self or what ever it is called, to really connect with the true me. 
So I know about performing a person in public.  That is where I saw how so many people did everything and survived in the community and were quite happy with their lives, but they had a secret side to them, which wasn’t a “side” but their inner core that like me they kept safe from the full submission that can come from an honest approach and a love of God.  Therefore I could easily see the people that were putting it on, or acting it out.  Some sort of fooled themselves that what they were doing was correct and natural, and of course there were hidden social structures and connections between these secret selves that undermined the otherwise perfect community.  I hate to say, but it seemed to be most people, though some were trying and will get there eventually.
Anyhow, I could not do either, and certainly not keep up a pretence, so better to do nothing, and so I am typing this on Shabbat, and my only concession on the day is that I don’t shave.  It has given me a wonderful insight into how the Universal Mind might think, that mind that I believe exists but to which I have not submitted.
Islam, the Religion, teaches submission to the will of God exactly as Judaism had done.  In ancient religions such as Egypt and the Hellenic and Roman Mystery Cults, a priestly elite passed on the meditative practices that delivered the blissful life.  This was not shared with the bulk of the population.  Judaism was different in that it was to be a “nation of priests” so the techniques were not secretly held by the Cohanim,  though the stream of authentic knowledge was shifting to the Rabbinic, Pharisees.   However, by the time it was redacted and written down it had become the exclusive opportunity for only those prepared to study hard.  However, the promise of eternal bliss may be the reason such a large proportion of the Israeli population devote their lives to study.  Oddly, they do not seem to understand that it can be combined with a life in the wide world, and indeed is better when it is.  The move to make army service combined with Yeshiva study for everyone eqully would have totally transformed Israel into a totally Shomre Mitzvot society.  It was stopped by the religious people who did not see the benefits.  The idea of being soldiers in the cause of spreading the Will of God somehow dies not appeal to many theoretically trained minds. 
This is where the national groups that have adopted Islam as their religion have gone off the rails, too.  They are soldiers, hoping to die as Holy Martyrs.  The God who loved the “Sweet”smell of the animal sacrifices on the altar in Jerusalem, must equally love Sons of Islam, followers of The Prophet (pbuh)  who fight each other in the name of the One True God, and make Holy Martyrs of each other as human sacrifice to the Will of God.  Everyone dies, but only some die nobly for the ultimate cause.
Only a few, largely self-selected, men studied the Talmud, Zohar and other texts  and learnt submission, but they would have achieved a blissful life.  Many communities were lucky enough to have such a person, and it is little wonder that such people are held in awe by their communities, such as the Lubavitcher Rebbe.  Even in a religion called “submission” it is evident that too many people quickly assume that because they have mastered the rituals and memorised everything thy know everything and their ideas are best for everyone, but they do not know their ideas are very limited and do not apply to everyone. 
If the religious authorities in Iraq were to revive the Jewish centre of learning in Babylon, and teach the traditions of Judaism through the filter of Islam, then something truly wonderful would result.  It would be greater that an equivalent Academy in Jerusalem where Islam is taught from a Jewish perspective.  The two religions are so similar.  Living in the world was the way the Saducees lived, in opposition to the cloistered life.  Everything is a duality, but the best solution is a synthesis of the duality, combining the best of both sides.  (See New Whig for a socio-political version of all this.)  One day there will be Peace on Earth.  Suddenly people will see that they have lived in the Garden of Eden all the time.  The expulsion was purely mental, but how many thousands of years will it take for people to return to a State of Nature, being part of the Ecosystems of the Natural World as well as the social systems and other systems of organisation, including in the virtual dimension.  It is only a few decades now to the bimillenial anniversary of the Temple’s destruction.  It is pleasing to think it might be rebuilt, and with the new ground penetrating technology they are sure to find the Arc of the Covenant that was never retrieved for the Second Temple, but will be for the third.
Then again lightning can strike the open iron alter at the top of Mount Zion and kindle the fire for the sacrifices once again.  I am a vegetarian, but I accept that most people are not, and if animals are to be slaughtered for food they should be recognised as sentient beings whose souls are also part of the divine Universal Consciousness.   The ancient temples were butcher shops.  I have been to the Kali Temple above the west bank of the Kali River that borders Nepal, and seen the blood sacrifices in the temple courtyard, seen the vultures circling for abandoned flesh, and seen people of various castes come for the carcases.  It saddens me that I shall not live to see it.  All I can do is imagine it, and write this and post it to a blog that is not read and may never be read. 

Thursday, 10 September 2015

Congratulations to Her Majesty



Congratulations to Her Majesty on attaining the history-book-entry milestone of becoming the longest reigning British Monarch.  Probably forever, assuming the Monarchy lasts forever, and presently it looks certain, for the next couple of centuries at least.  It is possible future generations that are born into a constantly changing world of infinite diversity will come to appreciate the long-term stability and certainty of Monarchy. 
There are repeated comparisons to Her Imperial Majesty Queen Victoria.  We all know The Queen through her lifetime, even more so recently with all the retrospective photographs, including Her Majesty when a very young queen.   Queen Victoria is best remembered as she was in later life and it is only recently that historians and writers have revived the young Queen Victoria.  History’s Queen Victoria was defined by the last decade of her reign.  At a mere ninety, The Queen is very probably going to reign over us for at least another decade, as I am sure that privately our queen will want to outlive her own mother, Her Imperial Majesty Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Mother. 

Tuesday, 8 September 2015

New Dawn, remember this date, 8th September, 2015

Hot the much mail-delayed letter from my Oncologist.  Most amasing, he treats me like someone who will understand, and I do understand.  I think this is what makes me feel better, not just his detailed prognosis which suggests a good chance of success.
They know the probabilities of success but nor clearly the causes.  Perhaps it is a matter of probability like quantum effects.  Perhaps it is the result of genuine quantum effects at a human scale.

Here is my reply:  Which I shall now edit, so it might be different.  Whom am I telling with this blog? No one at present, but if I do live another couple of decades, who knows?



1225 High Street, Armadale Vic 3143                                               8th September 2015

Dear Professor Millar,

Thank you for your very re-assuring letter dated 24th August that arrived today.  Rather pathetically I confess, that you are the first person ever who has taken a letter of complaint of mine seriously and responded in a way I can understand and that actually addresses my concerns and does not patronise me – and I have written hundreds of such letters for many reasons I was distressed, not just medical.  Thank you.

You probably wonder why I have not searched the InterNet myself and found these studies.  Especially considering I have done tertiary studies that were totally On Line, so I am not only proficient but accomplished having gained a High Distinction with Open University.  But I have digressed into a rare moment of personal pride and optimism, brought on no doubt, by the very positive prognosis implied by the many studies you quote.  I could draw a ‘tree’ (I forget the name) that allocates percentages to the quotas from previous percentages, especially if it included margins of errors or standard deviations and so forth.  Again, I digress, but my point is that I am liable to ‘self harm’ as Alexandra (the last Counsellor to quit on me, who promised she never would, though it was arguably a problem of bureaucracy not hers personally,) identified it in my behaviour.  I used to wonder if I was cursed!  This was brought on by child-hood trauma that went un-treated for decades and made worse by me being very introverted.  I think I avoid doing things that I can do and which would benefit myself, like presently avoiding getting a plumber, as I need to every year or two, to clear the street-tree roots from the sewer.  Anyhow, reading your concise digest of the pertinent research provides me in a page what many hours of research might give me, once I had worked out how to filter the relevant from all the other studies that get reported, with or without peer-review.  No wonder Hospital and Medical Departments do not regularly try to impart this sort of information, but I wonder how other people cope.  Oh!  I just remembered, most people are more optimistic than I am.  I think it is a sort of skewed, normal distribution, with people being born optimistic with most people tending towards optimism with the mean far above the mode, and increasing levels of pessimism with no actual upper limit.  I exist in a stratified region in this and many other demographic distributions.  Excuse me for telling you all this, but you can understand me and perhaps will find it interesting. 

All I wanted to do was thank you for your letter.  When the first of the post-operative PSA results came in, I had an appointment on the Friday with Dr Langdon before my scheduled appointment on the following Tuesday with Mr Hanegbi.  The result was tiny.  Point zero Zero three, if I remember correctly or three thousandths of one percent, if my arithmetic is correct.  Dr Langdon seemed very pleased with this infinitesimally tiny result and congratulated me on the success of the operation, which confirmed Mr Hanegbi’s post-operative comment that he had removed more tissue than the minimal and was sure everything had been cleaned.  I felt wonderful, especially as I had been having great success with the Counselling from the other, chronic problem.  I cannot tell you how excellent I felt.  Suddenly I noticed that all sorts of other things, both physical and psycho-social were cleared up.  Then on Tuesday, Mr Hanegby gave me the expert opinion: the result was small but was not zero.  Had I not read in the literature to hope for zero?  Yes I had.  I understand the mathematical difference between something that approaches zero and zero, and that is the greatest ontological difference two entities, states of being or members of a set can have.  Someone later told me that the degree of accuracy of these tests is improving rapidly.  The test a while back might have show zero, but that would have been a false (positive or negative, I am dyslexic and confuse them?) I forget who told me, not yourself, I think, but it does not matter.  The dramatic, earth shattering news was that I was not free and needed more treatment. 

Why does all this treatment take so long to start?  Why wasn’t I given or offered the hormones when I was first diagnosed with even a tiny amount of Cancer?  Then I was told to wait as few men have it progress in their lifetimes.  Why wasn’t I it started as soon as the need for the operation was diagnosed, for the treatments to run together.  There were three weeks between the ghastly, fatal biopsy and the operation itself.  Three weeks of turning my mind off and not thinking about anything except the preparation exercises and work and other important duties.  I did go to the theatre as a kind of last treat, just in case, and luckily they were two of the best and amongst the few memorable theatrical experiences.  Then I waited another three months for another PSA test, which would have been zero in two circumstances: I had been on the hormone androgen deprivation which I was not, or the operation had removed every trace of the cancerous prostate cells. My PSA had risen three-fold, as I recall and I was referred to you.

You are aware of the next blow to my self-esteem when I gained the knowledge that it might have been possible to avoid the operation, and its side-effects, and go straight to the treatment you were offering.  I still do have concerns about that choice having been made for me.  I accept that it may have been the best choice in the circumstances.  I am still not sure why a man such as myself is not put immediately onto the androgen deprivation.  It would seem that the cancer is put on hold for the duration and may be wiped out.  For those men who come off the treatment, surely an operation is then still possible.

On Friday, I am attending your clinic for the scan in preparation for the Ray Treatment (I don’t want to think about it)  but I do not anticipate seeing you, which is why I am writing this letter.   Thank you for reading it if you have gone this far.  If it did nothing more but amuse you with my pretentions of cleverness, then I am still happy, because writing it has given me a chance to work through the delight and existential optimism your mail-delayed letter has given me.  It has tunnelled through my layers of pessimistic introversion to give me hope for the future.  On that point I should add that death in itself holds no fears for me as to me it seem obvious that beyond each end of our temporal existence the same non-existence exists, if “zero” can be said to actually have real, ontological existence, apart from a point on a made-up, heuristic number line.  However, I do enjoy being alive and have today resubscribed to the MTC, surely the act of someone who anticipates survival.  Thank you.

Yours sincerely,

Norman F Pollack                                                                   Copy: Mr Hanegbi, Dr Langdon

Monday, 7 September 2015

Public Transport in Victoria



Public Transport in Victoria should be totally re-organised.  The current strikes of trams and trains reveal the out-dated state of this vital service.  The Australian Colonies had no history of change, but had institutions set up from afar which were assumed to be permanent and inviolate.  We persist with these dinosaurs of public activity.
The practice of decisions over people’s lives being made by others is Feudal.  That “managers” still decide issues of rostering, hours, training and so on, without discussion with the “workers” themselves is counter to the egalitarian principles crucial to Australia.  These disputes are not about the details of the claim, but about the power of wage-earners over their own lives.  It is a classic example of Marxist ‘alienation’.  Instead of the Green-Left and  the Red Left  preaching against “capitalism” they should direct their energies towards systems like Public Transport, but also Health and Education, where these feudal divisions into classes persists and holds back the modernisation and efficient operation of these systems.
Of all countries, Australian society is strongest in our belief in equality.  This may have been sourced in the Aboriginal Cultures that were more influential in many aspects of the Australian character than have so far been acknowledged.  The Australian Army has been noted for the relationship between Officers and Personnel that was different from the Aristocratic traditions that persisted in most Armies into last century, and still survives. 
In the private, corporate world, the problem is not the Economic structure of Free Enterprise but the persistence of the artificial class divisions into managers and workers.  This vaguely corresponds to the academic an Associative division of occupations into Professions and Trades.   This same distinction has persisted in Government and semi-Government bureaucracies and throughout the Public Service including the privatised parts of it.  This shows that the problem is Social and endemic and not the consequence of the Political structures called Capitalism.  It is because it survives in areas like Public Transport that we have the problems leading to these strikes.  Nationalising all industry, the aim of the Left, would result in everything being run like Public Transport.
If ever “Worker Control” was applicable, it is surely in the Government owned, if no longer Government run, systems like Public Transport.  Whether it is through the existing Unions or via new forms of Corporate Governance, we need to bring the people who do the work into the decisions about the work.  The same holds for the important but maligned Professions of Teaching and Nursing.   
The shake-up needs to go much further than employee-relations.  The balance between public and private transport also need to be addressed.  Australia cannot remain a car-based society for ever.  In cities on other continents, most private journeys are by public transport, but in Melbourne, probably the worst of the Australian Capital Cities, it is less than a quarter.  This can only be changed with a clear lead from Government.  Except that Spring Street is stuck in the Colonial past.  While small improvements to the train and tram network are important, including eventually removing all the suburban level crossings, they will only make a slight difference. 
Busses are the obvious solution.  Not just greater frequency on existing routes, but creating a network of new bus routes that can replace at least half of the cars that choke our roads and clog our freeways.  It would be a major manufacturing industry.  It would also replace the petrol motors of cars with the non-polluting fuel cells of modern busses.   This should all be done by an Authority that includes the people who will make and operate the busses.   Having just installed the outrageously expensive Miki system in Melbourne, it would need to stay till it has recouped its investment,  perhaps a decade, but then, as should have happened before, Public Transport should be made free.  The costs of selling tickets exceed the revenue.  The public subsidy for public transport would be less if it were free, per capita use, though usage would greatly increase, and free transport is a good incentive for people to switch from driving their own car to going by bus, tram or train. 
Foolishly, many of these same people that persist with the colonial bureaucracies want a Republic.  They naively thing such a symbolic change will have a top-down effect and correct all our social ills.  This is obviously absurd, but they presumably know it because they usually preach a minimalist change to a republic, pretending such a transformation were possible, and ignoring the unforeseen but certain major ramifications that would follow removing the Crown from the Constitution.

Sunday, 6 September 2015

just angry tody

Listening to ABC radio leads to distress.  Not a good lie-in at all.  Firstly about stolen Aboriginal wages in WA.  Millions stolen, eventual recognition of the problem and a slow process of correcting it, except that the final outcome is a minimal token to the few people who have survived the drawn out recognition of their rights.  The way Aboriginal people were treated is horrific.  It still persists, and worse, many Australians retain the mentality of approval or denial of this horror.  If Tony Abbott thinks Daesh is equivalent to the Jewish Holocaust, then he should look at the continual official treatment of Australia's first nations and the descendants of the long-term owners of this country.

Then came an interview about "drugs".  Portugal legalised all drugs fifteen years ago and since then heroin use has halved, AIDS transmission ceased, all drug use fell, and so forth.  The writer of a new book is speaking in Australia.  The arguments are so persuasive, yet the situation remains in Australia.

No wonder I feel resentment when in the presence of Medicos or Lawyers, the people who should be leading our society but instead are holding it back.  Pace "doctors' wives" the supposed majority component of the "new left" including the Greens and the Socialist Left, whose policies are as extreme, unrealistic and counter-productive as the Right.

I should be posting this publicly, but who listens to me?  I just make enemies, draw attention from undesirables and attract interest from the private, secretive "public" authorities.

I wrote something about public transport, yesterday, that I haven't yet posted to New Whig, that I am thinking of promoting, but my thoughts continue to be about the Nature Strip, and I might write something about that and promote it widely.  If I am to bring about one change in my lifetime, what little is left, then stopping the poisoning of endemic wild-flowers and mowing grasslands, all part of the recognition of Country, will be eternally worthwhile.

Yesterday I felt terrible.  Lunch went really well, but when I returned to Billy's later, I made us canned soup and ended up on his couch, almost asleep and went home early. The problem was partly his choice of programmes.  the Lilly Tomlin sitcom with Riba Macantyer (sp?), Malibu Country, was entertaining to start with, except now it is a total bore, except that the Lilly Tomlin character smokes weed and campaigns for it in the show.  That is good to see.  Marijuana is openly praised on television and normalised into family life in sitcoms.  On the MTV Video Awards show, they did a "3,2,1, Marijuana" cheer and gave their top award to a user and campaigner for drug normalisation.  Today, however, I don't feel too terrible, and will go to the city first for lunch and then tram to St Kilda to see Bad Jews at the new Alex Theatre.

The