I am not a Vegan. I
drink milk and consume the products of the Cow. I eat honey and wear woollen clothes. I like to think that only contented cows give
milk, ensuring that my cows’ lives are not unduly unpleasant on my
account. I like to remember that they
would not be alive at all if it were not for my milk consumption, and surely
any life is better than no life. If all
the World became Vegan, then our Domesticated Cattle species would be reduced
to a few examples in zoos and eventually become totally extinct – after millennia
of a symbiotic, ecological relationship.
However, there are ways of the world that I wish were
different, and wool is one. My personal
experiences ‘in the bush’ have been minimal and long, long ago, but I did go
out one day in the rain and help ‘mark’ the lambs, as I recall the name for
putting a tight rubber band on all their tails and round all the baby rams’
balls, so they would all fall off and avoid ‘dags and create weathers. At least they were not using the traditional
method of two bricks. On another
occasion, I saw a paddock full of rams and I understand why farms do what they
do and why most people are better off remaining ignorant, unlike myself with my
single day’s experience.
One hopes that even lambs being led to be slaughtered have
at least had a few happy moments experiencing maternal love of the sort that
was a popular topic for artists through the Middle Ages and into the Renaissance. Surely those few moments of transcendent
bliss are sufficient to make their short lives worthwhile. As a species, we like to imagine ourselves
outside the Natural Order, but it is the nature inherent in each living being
that comes into life to ultimately be food for some other, larger creature:
Nature is constantly consuming itself.
Only our species, at the pinnacle of the food-chain die uneaten, only to
eventually be consumed by worms or bacteria.
While I feel that being Vegetarian is right for me, I cannot
bring myself to become a Vegan, because the products of the animals are
different from the animals themselves.
However, I recognise that the industries that make these products available,
derived from ancient cottage-industries, have a negative side that is best kept
out of sight. Instead of campaigning for
the world to become Vegan, activists would have more chance of meaningful
results by campaigning for better rights for the animals that give their
products instead of ignoring them in the wider claim to end all animal farming.
No comments:
Post a Comment